To fake or not to fake, that is the question writes,
Here’s an interesting one for you: OK, so I’m a petite girl who grew up extremely flat chested, and though I never necessarily lacked for girl friends or male attention I was always ALWAYS aware of it and self-conscious about it. Right after I graduated college I went and did something about it — got modest breast implants (I wasn’t even an A, now I’m a 34C). I only told a few close college friends (who were very supportive) and then moved to a different city where I made a bunch of new friends. I’ve gained about 10 pounds since college, so of the maybe twice since I got them that an ‘uninformed’ college friend has made an offhand comment, I’ve blamed it on the weight gain and birth control pill hormones (which COULD be possible for all they know!).
Because they are so subtle on my frame (truly!), and I’m not the stereotypical ‘breast implant type’ of girl, none of my new friends has ever suspected. I’m quite comfortable with my intelligent, quirky indie chick (and therefore not ‘breast implant type’ chick) status and the majority of my friends are similarly inclined. I don’t regret getting the implants and I really love filling out my clothes better than before, but I don’t flaunt them and I obviously don’t advertise it. I just don’t think everybody needs to know!
I usually make it a point to hook up with guys who are outside of my friend circle because I don’t want to take the chance of being ‘outed’ to my friends somehow. None of these post-college relationships have been long-term enough to make my breasts a serious topic of discussion between me and the guy and most have either naively not noticed (and just think I have a awesome perky breasts) or, if they suspected, have not, at least to my knowledge, ever gotten word back to any of my new friends.
The problem now is that things are starting to heat up a bit between me and a close friend of some friends, and could potentially lead to more than just short-term drunken fondling. So far it hasn’t progressed passed the making out stage, but I’m definitely interested in more, and opportunities for this may arise sooner rather than later. So, my question is: what do I do about this guy? He’s what you might call an intellectual, and would quite possibly be put off by the thought of a girl with breast implants (I could hope that my personality would sway his opinion otherwise, but who knows?). There’s always a slight chance that he wouldn’t notice, but there’s a better chance that he will.
We are friends, yes, but not the super close-for-years kind where I can just bring it up and explain myself before he, um, notices for himself. And it’s not like some deeply buried secret that I can wait until we are more serious to discuss!
I really like this guy, but do I sabotage my chance with him to maintain my discretion? Should I tell him up front? If you were this guy would you be weirded out by the cute ‘non breast implant type’ girl secretly harboring breast implants after all? If you were this guy would you mention it to your buddies (who would, in turn, possibly mention it to my friends)? Your input would be very helpful! Thanks!
Follow-up:
I just had a thought that you guys might advise me to subtley make a joke about or otherwise bring up implants and see what his reaction is and take my cue from that, but I would imagine that whatever his true feelings, he would say something negative, if just because he thinks that that’s what I would want to hear, being a “non breast implant” type girl and all, so that probably wouldn’t be too productive.
You don’t have to post this follow up, just please don’t advise the above unless you can think of another reason that it may be a viable option. I really think I’ve thought this over from so many possible angles and am at an impasse, hence why I’m after your (wise and) unbiased opinions. There are very few people I can bounce the problem off of since my close friends here that have met him and know the details of our budding relationship are post-college and have no idea about my “secret”. My mom knows but, well, that’s just weird, haha.
Kathryn says,
I don’t see any reason you have to tell him, at least not until he has reason to come into close contact with your enhanced curves. I say, if/when he’s ever feeling you up (sans bra), in between kisses say something like, “I guess you can tell I’ve had a little help here; hope you don’t mind.” Be sure to say this extra breathily. I’m sure he won’t mind at all.
And if for some reason he does think any less of you for having them, I would have to imagine he’s not worth your energy anyway. And if he feels the need to tell his friends in a juvenile, gossipy manner, that goes double.
DCB says,
I’m guessing the point of getting breast implants was so you would have one less thing to worry about. Yet you are still worrying about it!
While it is hard for me to accurately answer your question without seeing a photo of your breasts, I do know that guys don’t really care about implants as long as they aren’t big and gross like those bolt-ons you commonly see in porn.
I disagree with Kathryn about mentioning it in passing. Don’t say anything about it unless he brings it up. And even if he does, stick to the facts: “Yes, I had breast implants years ago.” Don’t make a joke about it, don’t say why you did it, and don’t rationalize it in any way. You made the choice to do this for you so there is no reason to justify it or make yourself uncomfortable for any man. If he can’t handle your breasts then forget him. (If I liked a girl’s chest, it does not matter to me if they are real or not. But I’m an ass man so that’s a moot point.)